Critics of Spain's tiki-taka success have misinterpreted their dominance as a sign of boring football.
Believing such tactical mastery deserves condemnation fails to recognise the genius that creates such overwhelming supremacy.
67.5% possession, 3096 passes made with 89.6% completed, 18.6 shots per game with 8 on target, 7 shots against them per game with only 1 goal conceded. And yet people still moan that the World Champions are boring.
Barcelona's and Spain's unparalleled 21st century successes have revolutionised football tactics, creating, developing and instigating a new philosophy that has outright destroyed any previous models of footballing excellence.
Emerging under Johan Cruyff in the 90s, Barcelona adapted Dutch total football – relying on player speed and positional fluidity – to one based on ball retention and pass speed, not player speed.
The pass-and-move approach requires obsessive repetition and hard work: exponents of the philosophy are expected to perform with relentless perfection. It is this combination of technical assurance and religious knowledge that makes tiki-taka such a complex and paradoxical beauty. It is a system modelled on elegance, creativity and exquisite football, yet paradoxically is constrained and contained within the narrow parameters set by constant repetition, until seemingly ingenious fluidity is reduced to instinct and simplicity.
It elevates humans to awe-inspiring levels of beauty and sublime, reduces humans to perfected machines. Yet recently, disturbing grumbles have begun to flutter in the recesses of the English media, as critics have finally, after years of low scoring matches, dared to utter the phrase, 'boring'.
The Spanish reacted angrily, disregarding the critics as philistines and misunderstanders of football's tactical, intellectual beauty. Sid Lowe reflected on the cultural implications of these descenting voices, positing that English football reflects the unexpected, Spanish football the technical: “That dichotomy says something about footballing cultures, the value placed on technique and endeavor, respectively[...] We cry out for the unexpected; football teams want to know what's coming. Few sides have ever achieved that quite as Spain is doing.” Spain are so reliable, so consistently excellent, matches no longer retain the excitement of uncertainty. But the reasons for any competitive-less tedium are not the Spaniards' responsibility.
If an absence of end-to-end entertainment translates as 'boring', then the blame for this actuality lies not in the style itself, but in the opposition response to the tiki-taka threat. The more they dominate possession, the deeper the defence drop. As Spain's dominance grows, scoring becomes harder. Xavi's angry response to this claim perfectly encapsulates the reasons for Spain's uneventful encounters: “What did people think? That we were going to win every game 3-0? I can't believe what I am hearing sometimes. Do you not realize how hard it is? Teams aren't stupid; we're European champions. They all pressure us like wolves. There isn't a single meter, not a second on the pitch. We are passing faster and faster and faster. We're playing bloody brilliantly.”
Tiki-taka has become so lethal, proficient, and impossible to contain, that teams are increasingly sacrificing their own football and defending extremely deeply. Indeed, some are even suggesting that Chelsea's semi-final victory over Barcelona indicated the Spanish philosophy has been 'found out'. Although this is immediately negated by the overwhelming successes of the national side, Chelsea's win may help to explain the increasing appearance of boring, unimaginative football. Chelsea's victory has become a byword for deep defensive lines, and although the constant reference to their victory is tiresome, this example has become so universally acknowledged that it has genuinely affected the way teams approach games against Barcelona or Spain.
The short-passing game is relentlessly carried to its extreme, as determined by the tiki-taka paradox. When the opposition abandon traditional counter methods and sit deep and compact, the opportunities to weave passes together and create goalscoring opportunities become progressively fewer. The patience and diligence of this style, however, means players refuse to pander to yearnings for excitement and unpredictability. Instead, with a terrifying and machine-like consistency, they continue to slowly coax the opposition out and exploit any minor chinks in their armour: 'You might give two passes that seem to lack any value but the third may be the decisive one', in the words of Xabi Alonso.
Anyone believing such tactical mastery deserves condemnation has failed to recognise the genius that creates such overwhelming dominance. Simply put, opposing teams are not good enough to make the style 'entertaining', in the traditional sense. Sid Lowe proposes that “it is the Spaniards' very brilliance that makes their games seem uneventful[...] Their opponents simply can't touch them. Maybe they are simply forced back. Maybe the blame for the lack of classic, end-to-end contests involving Spain actually lies with opponents that simply can't match them.”
If fans find this boring, then they may be more comfortable with a different sport. The tactical proficiency and constancy is both frightening and compelling – the 'boring' nature of their games is, conversely, a testament to their immense talent. Never before in the history of football has one team presented such possessional dominance, forcing oppositions to abandon their tactics. Even Mourinho, after failing to overcome Barcelona in his first season, ultimately resorted to deep and compact defending: "If you have a Ferrari and I have a small car,” Mourinho explained, “the only way I can win is by putting sugar in your petrol tank."
True footballing perfection is not founded in flair but in consistency, and this is achieved by the tiki-taka style in ways that did not seem possible a decade ago.
An emerging argument attached to dissenting voices of 'boring' football is that a more convincing system of success could be implemented in Spain, given the vast array of talent at their disposal. With a squad blessed with a perfect blend of Madrid and Barcelona stars, it is easy to see why some believe a different approach could unlock the individual talent of the side with greater efficiency, creating a side that wins 5-0 instead of 1-0. But Spain are achieving unparalleled success with their current system, despite its unwillingness to nurture the expressive and expansive capabilities of players like Silva, Pedro, or Torres.
The style relies on possession stats above 65%, and pass completion figures as high as 90%. Although a more traditional approach could ultimately find more pockets of space for entertaining footballers, they would not reach anything like these numbers; and it is the numbers that contribute to their defence, as much as their attack.
It is a common misconception that tiki-taka is based purely on attacking football; the reality is a dependence on simplicity, patience and pragmatism, in all phases of play. Ahead of the quarter-final victory over France, coach Laurent Blanc highlighted the fundamental problem teams face against Spain: "When do you adapt to a team? When they have the ball. The problem with Spain is that they average 65 to 70 percent of possession. So you're left with a third of possession. But for 70 percent of the game, you have to adapt to Spain because they have the ball and you don't.”
Blanc has inadvertently revealed the underlying factor in the 'boring' nature of Spain games: their opponents, spending the vast majority of the game without possession, are not allowed to play in their own style. When in possession, the interplay is yours to mould: when not in possession, you must adapt to the opponents. If adapting becomes the primary structure (for 70% of the match), then how can any team realistically set themselves out to achieve their personal objectives? “You could go for it and play with four forwards, but the problem is that your wingers would spend the game playing next to their own corner flags."
The defensive solidity guaranteed by dominating possession is not restricted to this inability of the opposition to attack: it is also a matter of fitness. Not only are the opposition too tired to muster attacking threat, and not only are they too tired to avoid being tackled by their Spanish counterparts, but Spain know that with patience and determination, they will eventually break the exhausted ranks, and win.
The fitness disparity between the two teams is easy to understand: players are required to work significantly harder off the ball than on it. After Spain's 1-0 victory over Germany in the World Cup semi-final, Klose remarked: 'Spain forced us to run after the ball all night and that's hard. We should have forced them into mistakes but we didn't, we couldn't. We can only congratulate them, they had all the possession and we were running endlessly off the ball without stopping.” The Spanish kept going, and finally broke the Germans down in the 73rd minute.
The fitness of the opposition is rapidly depleted by this system, and this is complimented by the relative ease with which Spain can control possession. Their appearance of fitness is directly proportional to their opponents appearance of exhaustion. Raphael Honigstein writes that “it is such a devastating tactic because it's both defensive and offensive in equal measure. You don't have to switch from attack to defence or vice versa because you're always in possession. It's a significant upgrade of the Dutch "total football", a system that relied on players changing positions. The Spanish don't have to do that any more since the ball does all the hard work”.
The contrast in fitness levels created by this footballing philosophy is something the Spanish pounce on, capitalising on their significant stamina advantage by utilising a high pressing game. When they lose the ball, Spain's players harass their opponents, forcing them to hurriedly conceded possession. The opposing players are so tired, have so few players in advanced roles, and are so psychologically worn down by the dominance of Spain's passing, they inevitably, and almost immediately, concede possession back to the tiki-taka experts.
Invariably confronted by deeply defensive lines, Spain's excellence does not translate to dominant scorelines, mazy dribbling, or frequent one-on-one opportunities. It does, however, win them the match almost every time, achieving success with frightening consistency. It stunts the unpredictable excitement of football, and it prevents fans from viewing classic end-to-end matches.
That does not mean that it is not beautiful, and it certainly does not mean that it is boring. If you are bored watching the most rigorously orchestrated football tactic ever created, being implemented on the most talented footballers in the history of the sport, then maybe you should try watching something else. If you are bored of witnessing the most incredible feats of footballing dominance, characterised by inhuman levels of technical perfection and geometric intelligence, then this sport might not be for you.
The fluidity of Spain's passing and moving is scintillating, and extraordinary – the product of 20 years of rigorous training and youth development, that has culminated in the emergence of footballers with an almost telepathic understanding for one another. They caress the ball with effortless grace; and with a deceptive appearance of ease, have transformed football from a complex and enigmatic sport into a devastating mathematical art-form.
It is this revolution in our understanding of the sport that has led to a confused cry of 'boredom'. Attempts at countering the threat of this unique philosophy, unheard of until only ten years ago, has swiftly converted confident, attacking teams into cowering animals, desperately defending deep within their own half. We are witnessing the most stunning technical artistry and mathematical efficiency the game has ever seen.
The mightiest teams on the planet are falling to their knees, again and again. Uncompetitive? Maybe. Boring? definitely not.